Students affiliated to the ruling Nepal Communist Party demonstrate in Kathmandu protesting against the recently-unveiled political map of India, which shows the Nepali territories including Kalapani inside India. Photo: Republica
KATHMANDU, Nov 7: Nepal has said that any unilateral decision to change border demarcations would not be acceptable after a new political map released by the Indian government last week continued to include Kalapani and Lipu Lekh – at the tri-junction point between Nepal, India and China – in Indian territory.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MoFA) in a statement on Wednesday said that outstanding boundary issues should be resolved in consensus, after the Survey General of India released its new political map on October 31 to reflect changes in the status of Jammu and Kashmir following the abrogation of Article 370 of the Indian constitution.
Nepal and India during the third meeting of their Joint Commission held in 2014 had agreed to direct the Foreign Secretaries to work on the outstanding boundary issues, including Kalapani and Susta, with technical inputs from the Boundary Working Group. The Nepali side has been repeatedly expressing its desire to resolve all outstanding boundary issues including Kalapani, Lipulekh and Susta.
The official statement from MoFA comes days after the new Indian political map caused a public outcry, with student bodies taking to the street and senior political leaders urging the government to take diplomatic initiatives to resolve matters. “Nepal government is clear that remaining outstanding boundary issues should be resolved through mutual consensus and any unilateral decision won’t be acceptable,” a MoFA statement said on Wednesday.
Although the controversy over inclusion of Kalapani as Indian territory has surfaced again this week, Indian political maps have continued to put these territories in its side of the border almost since the 1960s. In an interview with BBC Nepali Service, Surveyor General of India Lt Gen Girish Kumar argued that this was not something that India had done for the first time.
“We’ve been using this map for a few decades. Almost since the partition of India. Speaking of maps, this time we have not made the map of the country’s border changed,” the BBC quoted Kumar as saying.
With people taking exception to the new Indian political map and increasingly questioning the government’s resolve to safeguard Nepal’s territory, the MoFA statement further said that the government is committed to safeguarding its international border and is firm in its belief that the border issues between the two countries should be resolved through diplomatic channels on the basis of historical documents and evidence.
In the BBC interview, Indian Surveyor General Kumar has implicitly accepted the existence of boundary issues. “Nepal does not have to accept what we are saying. But we have the right to say what we believe,” he said when asked about Nepal’s position that Kalapani belongs to it.
It may be recalled that Nepal had objected to an agreement reached between India and China during the visit of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to China in 2015 to boost trade through the Lipu Lekh Pass without Nepal’s involvement. Nepal maintained that it was against international norms and values to make such an agreement when Nepal and India are yet to resolve outstanding boundary issues.
Foreign affairs experts in Kathmandu have suggested the government ask India not to put out any map that alters the status quo until this issue is resolved bilaterally through the proposed foreign secretary-level mechanism, if not from the highest political level.
“There is enough evidence that Nepal’s westernmost boundary with India goes beyond the areas of Lipulekh and Kalapani inside Nepal’s territory,” said former foreign secretary Madhu Raman Acharya. “Nepal should ask India to withdraw any map that alters the status quo unilaterally until the boundary issues are resolved bilaterally.”