Promises of prosperity from Rara Lake last year look elusive

Published On: April 14, 2019 04:30 AM NPT By: Rudra Pangeni  | @rudrapang

KATHMANDU, April 14: On Baishak 1 last year, Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli had addressed the citizens with a New Year message from Rara Lake in western Nepal. The emphasis of his speech was economic prosperity and distribution of development dividend.

Development, improved management in project handling, investment-friendly environment, curb on corruption, and tapping of natural resources were the key agendas of his high-sounding televised speech delivered nearly two months after assuming office.

Looking back today at the government's performance of the past one year, not much worth mentioning is seen. The economic growth may be as high as 6 percent this year driven by better crop output and service sector contribution. But growth of real the sectors—industry and manufacturing—are still to recuperate.

Economists say they find the government's first year performance to be just an average, and that it does not give any positive outlook.

"There is nothing to be hopeful in the past one year. The strongest government seems to have almost failed to bring in reforms in the fundamentals of the economy and expedite works in developments projects," said economist Keshav Acharya.

The high growth mainly driven by better crop output and service sector is a positive thing, but by itself this is not sufficient to address the chronic problems of the economy. Economists say this will not address the liquidity crisis in the market and will not break the rising trade deficit.

The service sector-based growth of economy does not ensure even distribution of economic output, which will be limited to few groups including traders, according to Acharya.

The government's few initial steps in March and April last year, namely ending syndicate in transportation and booking non-performing civil contractors sitting on development projects, were widely hailed. But the strides on those areas stopped later without any clear explanation.

Hopes of timely execution of development projects have been shattered. Mid-term review of the first budget of KP Oli government in March showed the same bleak picture in spending money for the development projects. The taxpayer's money is stuck in treasury vault while the shortage of cash runs deep in the market.

Finance Minister Yuba Raj Khatiwada admitted failure to do anything toward boosting development works, stating that the progress of such works is largely dependent on the line ministries.

"It seems economic transition still prevails here even though political transition has come to an end," Khatiwada had told the media.

Few days after assuming office in February, Khatiwada had issued a white paper blaming previous governments for financial indiscipline. But like his predecessors, Khatiwada's term also saw expenses at the eleventh hour. His budget spending in the last months was 20 percent, or Rs 222 billion, of the total expenses of Rs 1084 billion in the year ending mid-July. Such last minute spending is almost always mired by substandard work and corruption.

In his speech delivered from Rara Lake, the PM had pledged to controlling all kinds of malpractices in project management and having zero-tolerance on corruption. But KP Oli is silent on Melamchi Water Supply Project, which has turned into sick status due to double whammy of corruption and ill-management since December. He has not spoken a single word on the project in his public talks, although he is fond of delivering frequent public speeches.

Likewise, PM Oli had visited Upper Tamakoshi Project in April last year before heading off to Rara Lake and directed the project management to complete the project at the earliest. A year has been elapsed since then, and instead of completion, the project has got deadline extension by at least one year. The reason has been non-performance of an Indian contractor, and the project management has announced that it will complete the project by the end of 2019.

Both Melamchi and Upper Tamakoshi projects are national pride projects.

Likewise, the main canal of Sikta Irrigation Project, another national pride project, saw a major damage during a test. But the government remained silent for months on taking action against the involved officials. Later the contractor along with one and half dozen officials were charged of corruption.

Meanwhile, the progress in Gautam Buddha International Airport project has been remarkable. The work of Kathmandu Tarai Expressway is also progressing at a fast pace, but transparency in project administration by Nepal Army has been questioned. The work of laying petroleum pipeline from Amalekhgunj to India's Motihari is about to complete.

"Except these two projects, there is nothing to cheer about this government as nothing has been done toward stability of macro economy and improvement in trade balance," said Rameshore Khanal, former finance secretary.

Economist Acharya hailed the government's moves to prepare laws on public private partnership and foreign investments among others. "But I am disheartened to see the government failing to expedite capital spending and intervening in project managements," lamented Acharya.

The government, which was under pressure to do something after foreign direct investment plummeted significantly in the first six months of the current fiscal year, organized an investment summit in March to woo investors. But the necessary laws were endorsed in a hurry without needful debate.

In the speech, PM Oli had said: "We have problems in project management, there is weakness in vision and a lack of confidence, and there are malpractices. But we can resolve all these problems." The government will also do the needful to make people confident about government service delivery, PM Oli had said.

But after a year, tall promises remain flat. Problems remain almost the same, and nothing seems to be changing. The worry is: whether the dream of 'prosperous Nepal and happy Nepali' will remain a pipe-dream in the next four years of the current government.

Leave A Comment