KATHMANDU, Nov 20: As negotiations at the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31) enter their final and critical stage, the second draft of the conference's outcome document has raised serious concerns among developing countries, particularly those highly vulnerable to climate change. For Nepal, the question is not whether to walk away from the negotiations, but whether to endorse an agreement that fails to address its climate finance needs and the specific vulnerabilities of mountainous countries.
Climate activists and civil society representatives have criticized the revised draft, accusing it of weakening commitments to phase out fossil fuels, provide adequate climate finance and hold developed countries accountable for their historical emissions. They have urged developing countries not to endorse an agreement that could undermine their interests and leave vulnerable communities exposed to escalating climate risks.
Released after the initial document was made public on November 16, the second draft has been described by critics as even more regressive. They say it weakens the timelines, accountability mechanisms and provisions needed to protect communities bearing the brunt of the climate crisis.
For Nepal, the concerns go beyond broader commitments on fossil fuels and emissions reductions. The draft has also been criticized for failing to provide adequate assurances on access to climate finance, grant-based support, adaptation and loss and damage funding. These are critical issues for a country that contributes negligibly to global emissions but faces growing threats from melting glaciers, glacial lake outburst floods, landslides and other climate-induced disasters.
The removal of a proposed $120 billion climate adaptation finance target, provisions for grant-based financial assistance and safeguards related to debt payment suspensions has further heightened concerns among developing countries. Without predictable, accessible and additional financial resources, countries such as Nepal could struggle to invest in climate-resilient infrastructure, protect vulnerable communities and recover from climate-induced disasters.
The draft has also been criticized for giving greater prominence to carbon capture, utilization and storage (CCUS), carbon dioxide removal (CDR) and carbon markets, potentially diverting attention from the urgent need for actual emissions reductions. Equally concerning for Nepal is the inadequate recognition of the distinct challenges confronting mountainous countries. Rapid changes in mountain ecosystems, glaciers and water resources threaten livelihoods, biodiversity, agriculture, hydropower and downstream communities. Nepal should therefore work with other mountain and climate-vulnerable countries to ensure that their priorities are reflected in the final outcome.
SHIFT for Our Planet: Youths urge authorities to make climate j...
The inadequacy of the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage has also come under scrutiny. Despite requests for $2.8 billion in support, only around $342 million has been allocated, with just 50 percent of the pledged amount made available. The removal of a proposal to secure additional pledges by the end of 2027 has further deepened concerns about the fund's capacity to respond to the growing needs of vulnerable countries.
Critics have also pointed to the draft's failure to adequately recognize developed countries' historical responsibility and their obligations to provide climate finance. Provisions aimed at limiting global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius, along with mechanisms for scientific monitoring, have also reportedly been weakened.
With negotiations making little progress, calls are growing for developing countries to consider rejecting the proposed outcome. Panama has expressed opposition to the second draft, while other countries are reportedly preparing to support its position. Developing nations are also considering a united front to pressure major polluting countries to honor their commitments.
Harjeet Singh, global coordinator of the Fill the Fund campaign and founding director of the Satat Sampada Climate Foundation, said removing the clear commitment to gradually phase out fossil fuels and the fossil fuel roadmap proposed at COP30 was a serious setback. He argued that the climate crisis could not be addressed without tackling its primary source: fossil fuel emissions.
Civil society representatives have also urged developing country governments not to endorse an agreement that puts people's survival at risk. They have called on developed countries to provide adequate financial support for adaptation, loss and damage, and a just transition from fossil fuels to clean energy.
Nafkote Dabi, Global Climate Change Policy and Advocacy Lead at Oxfam International, urged countries including Nepal to reject what she described as a betrayal of climate-vulnerable communities.
She said the proposed outcome failed to deliver meaningful commitments on adaptation, climate finance and just transition, despite the urgent needs of countries still recovering from devastating climate disasters. "From adaptation to climate finance to just transition, the current text on the table fails to deliver anything meaningful to ensure communities are protected. Rich countries once again are failing to honor their commitment on climate finance. This is deeply disappointing and shameful," Dabi said, speaking exclusively to Republica.
Dabi called on countries in the Global South, including Nepal, to reject the draft unless it delivers tangible benefits to communities on the ground facing climate disasters.
Teresa Anderson, Global Lead on Climate Justice at ActionAid, also called for the rejection of the proposed outcome, saying it offered little to countries seeking to strengthen resilience against future disasters, rebuild after catastrophes or transition to greener pathways.
She said the draft lacked meaningful commitments on just transition, adaptation finance and climate finance more broadly. Instead, it contained what she described as a "cover-up decision" that promoted a few of the COP presidency's preferred projects while failing to address the needs of people on the ground.
Anderson urged Nepal and other least developed and developing countries to stand together against an agreement that offered little to those who had contributed least to the climate crisis but were suffering its worst impacts. "We cannot accept climate negotiations offering nothing for those who've done little to cause the crisis and yet are feeling the worst impacts," she said, calling on Nepal to help lead the opposition to the draft.
Climate activists have also stressed that developed countries must reduce their domestic carbon emissions in line with their historical responsibilities and respective capacities, while providing the financial and technological support developing countries need to address climate impacts and transition to cleaner energy.
For Nepal, the immediate priority should be to remain actively engaged in negotiations while building alliances with other climate-vulnerable and mountainous countries to push for a stronger outcome. It should seek clear commitments on predictable and accessible grant-based climate finance, adequate resources for loss and damage, and explicit recognition of the distinct climate challenges facing mountain nations.
Consensus should not come at the expense of climate justice. Nepal need not walk away from the negotiations, but it should be prepared to withhold its endorsement if the final agreement fails to address these fundamental concerns. A meaningful climate deal must not only set global targets but also ensure that vulnerable countries have the financial resources and international support to meet the challenges they face.