KATHMANDU, Dec 8: The Nepalese army on Wednesday reacted angrily to a study linking its UN peacekeepers to a cholera outbreak that has killed more than 2,000 people in Haiti.
The army said there was no evidence to support the conclusions of a respected French epidemiologist who was invited by the Haitian government to study the cause of the outbreak, the country´s first in decades.[break]
The United Nations has repeatedly insisted there is no proof any of its troops were responsible for introducing the infection to Haiti, but many local people still blame the peacekeepers.
"We strongly condemn the making of such allegations with no firm evidence or facts," Nepal army spokesman Ramindra Chhetri told AFP in Kathmandu, calling the report´s conclusions "hypothetical".
"I don´t think that we have seen any concrete evidence so far (linking the epidemic with Nepalese troops)."
A total of 90,000 Haitians have been infected since mid-October and experts say hundreds of thousands could eventually be hit by the disease in a country still struggling with the aftermath of a devastating earthquake in January which killed a quarter of a million people.
Cholera is caused by bacteria spread in contaminated water or food, often through faeces. If untreated, it can kill within a day through dehydration, with the old and the young the most vulnerable.
The results of cholera expert Renaud Piarroux´s research have not yet been published, but a source who asked not to be named told AFP it traced the infection to Nepalese soldiers serving in Haiti.
The infection must have originated from a UN base at Mirebalais on the Artibonite river in central Haiti that houses Nepalese peacekeepers, the source said.
"There is no other possible explanation given that there was no cholera in the country, and taking into account the intensity and the speed of the spread and the concentration of bacteria in the Artibonite delta," he added.
"The most logical explanation is the massive introduction of faecal matter into the Artibonite river on a single occasion."
Cholera is endemic in Nepal, and Haitian officials say the first cases in the latest outbreak were on the banks of the Artibonite river, downstream of the UN base.
Edmond Mulet, head of the UN mission in Haiti, said in November none of its soldiers had tested positive for cholera and all samples taken from the latrines, kitchens and water supply at the suspect camp had proved negative.
Nonetheless, many in Haiti blame the UN for the cholera outbreak, which came months after the deadly earthquake that left 1.3 million living in refugee camps.
The Nepalese contingent of just over 1,000 troops and police have been under special protection since demonstrations in November in which at least two people died.
Piarroux, who works at France´s University of the Mediterranean, said last month that the world had not seen cholera spread so quickly since an outbreak in Goma, in eastern Congo, in 1994.
"The epidemic exploded in an extremely violent way on October 19, with several thousand cases and several hundreds deaths after many people drank the water of the Artibonite delta," he said.
The French foreign ministry said it had received a copy of the report and passed it on to the United Nations for investigation.
About 12,000 UN personnel from dozens of countries are deployed in Haiti after years of armed conflict and the earthquake in January.
Haiti cholera outbreak ´came from UN camp´
PARIS: The cholera outbreak ravaging Haiti began at a camp for UN peacekeepers from Nepal, according to an expert report submitted to the French foreign ministry, a source close to the matter told AFP on Tuesday.
Respected French epidemiologist Professor Renaud Piarroux conducted a study in Haiti last month and concluded the epidemic began with an imported strain of the disease that could be traced back to the Nepalese base, the official said.[break]
"The source of the infection came from the Nepalese camp," the source told AFP, speaking on condition on anonymity as he was not authorised to discuss a report that has not yet been made public.
"The starting point has been very precisely localised," he said, pointing to the UN base at Mirebalais on the Artibonite river in central Haiti.
"There is no other possible explanation given that there was no cholera in the country, and taking into account the intensity and the speed of the spread and the concentration of bacteria in the Artibonite delta," he said.
"The most logical explanation is the massive introduction of faecal matter into the Artibonite river on a single occasion," the source added.
The United Nations, which has faced violent protests in Haiti over its alleged role in an outbreak that has already killed 2,000 people and made 90,000 sick, insists there is no evidence that its troops were to blame.
Foreign ministry spokesman Bernard Valero did not reveal the conclusion of the report, but confirmed the foreign ministry had received a copy and said it had been passed on to the United Nations for investigation.
"From the outbreak of the epidemic, France sent to Haiti at the request of the Haitian health ministry one of its best cholera specialists, Professor Piarroux, a head of department in Marseille´s public hospitals," he said.
Cholera has added to the woes of the impoverished Caribbean nation, which was devastated by a massive earthquake in January that killed a quarter of a million people and left 1.3 million living in ramshackle refugee camps.
Piarroux discussed his report in an interview with AFP last month. He did not directly blame the Nepalese, but said the cholera was from abroad.
"It started in the centre of the country, not by the sea, nor in the refugee camps. The epidemic can´t be of local origin. That´s to say, it was imported," he said, shortly after his return from Haiti.
Haitian officials say the first cases of cholera, a waterborne illness, broke out on the banks of the Artibonite river, downstream of the UN base.
Last month, Edmond Mulet, head of the United Nations mission in Haiti, said no UN soldier, police officer nor civilian official had tested positive for cholera, and he defended the Nepalese, who have been the target of protests.
All samples taken from the latrines, kitchens and water supply at the suspect Nepalese camp have proved negative, Mulet said.
"There is no scientific evidence that the camp at Mirebalais is the source of this epidemic," he said, complaining of "a lot of disinformation, a lot of rumours around this situation."
But Piarroux -- who works at the University of the Mediterranean in Marseille -- told AFP that the outbreak was not linked to the earthquake devastation, and could not have come from a Haitian environmental source.
"The epidemic exploded in an extremely violent way on October 19, with several thousand cases and several hundreds deaths after many people drank the water of the Artibonite delta," he said.
The professor said the world had not seen cholera spread so quickly since an outbreak in Goma, in eastern Congo, in 1994. "We´ve had more than 70,000 cases, and we could easily see them hit 200,000," he warned.
Cholera is caused by bacteria spread in contaminated water or food, often through faeces. If untreated, it can kill within a day through dehydration, with the old and the young the most vulnerable.
Related story
U.N. chief sorry for U.N. role in deadly Haiti cholera outbreak
_20210815071806.jpeg)
