SOCIETY

Proposed sexual violence bill falls short of protecting survivors

FWLD and Equality Now have called for five major reforms to the proposed sexual violence bill, including clearer consent provisions, equal penalties for marital rape and the removal of time limits for filing rape cases.
alt=
By REPUBLICA

KATHMANDU, Nov 17: The proposed bill on sexual violence prepared by the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs needs substantial revisions to ensure stronger legal protection for survivors, according to the Forum for Women, Law and Development (FWLD) and Equality Now.



Speaking at a media interaction jointly organized by the two organizations on Monday, FWLD Advocate Didkiksa Singh identified five areas requiring reform: the definitions of rape and consent, close-in-age exceptions, marital rape and the statute of limitations.


Presenting an advocacy paper, Singh said the legislation needed further amendments to ensure comprehensive protection against non-consensual sexual acts.


Related story

Proposed bill on sexual violence incomplete, legal reform group...


While the ministry's draft seeks to criminalize non-consensual sexual acts involving or between people of sexual and gender minorities, the paper recommends aligning the legislation with the UN Model Rape Law to ensure equal protection regardless of sex or gender identity. It also proposes criminalizing non-consensual penetration of the vagina, anus or mouth, to any extent, using any body part or object.


The paper recommends explicitly defining consent as voluntary agreement given through free will. It says consent should not be presumed based on a survivor's silence, lack of resistance, previous sexual history, profession or relationship with the accused. It also calls for amending Section 219(2)(b), replacing the vague phrase 'not in a sound state of mind' with clear criteria covering unconsciousness, sleep and intoxication, including the use of alcohol and drugs, as circumstances in which a person cannot give consent.


On close-in-age exceptions, the proposed bill provides for up to one year's imprisonment for consensual sexual relations between adolescents below 18 whose age difference is two years or less. The paper recommends fully decriminalizing such relations when both adolescents are at least 14 and the age difference does not exceed two years. However, cases involving fear, threats, inducement, exploitation or abuse of power should be excluded from this exception and remain subject to strict punishment.


The proposed amendment prescribes three to five years of imprisonment if a husband rapes his wife while their marriage remains legally intact. The paper recommends equal penalties for marital rape and other forms of rape, regardless of marital status. It also calls for completely removing the statute of limitations for filing rape cases to ensure survivors' access to justice and prevent perpetrators from escaping accountability.


Aakansha Saxena, South Asia Regional Communications Officer at Equality Now, welcomed Nepal's efforts to develop laws against sexual violence but stressed that effective implementation was as important as their formulation.


"Laws change when people understand why they are needed, and this is where the media comes in. Most people never read a legal clause, but they do read stories. So when a journalist tells what a survivor of sexual violence goes through to seek justice, that is when a law starts to matter to everyone else. The media is a catalyst for legal reform, and we need all hands on deck for laws that protect women and girls everywhere, without exception," she said.


The programme also highlighted statistics on sexual violence in Nepal and globally. FWLD Executive Director and Advocate Sabin Shrestha said many survivors do not come forward to file complaints, adding that the five proposed reforms could create a more supportive environment for them to seek justice.


FWLD Advocate Binu Lama also called for completely removing the statute of limitations to ensure survivors' access to justice.

Related Stories
SOCIETY

Sexploration season 2 Episode 1:Sex and porn educa...

season2ep1_20221218160154.jpg
OPINION

Gendered Experiences of Conflict-Related Sexual Vi...

Violence-1772151477.webp
POLITICS

TRC faces backlash over public call for sexual vio...

2AwYQuRP0Hf1pRKmq8pWl3wzyBhhfNkCYpeHuwL6.jpg
SOCIETY

Sexual violence cases against male street children...

Screenshot2023-04-13175817_20230413175832.png
My City

Safety and sexual violence: What do young girls ha...

sexualviolence_20220530180239.jpg