KATHMANDU, Nov 16: The proposed bill on sexual violence drafted by the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs needs further improvements, stakeholders have said. At an interaction with journalists jointly organised by the Forum for Women, Law and Development (FWLD) and Equality Now on Monday, participants presented recommendations for amendments, pointing out gaps in several provisions of the proposed legislation.
Presenting an advocacy paper on sexual violence at the event, FWLD lawyer Didriksha Singh said the bill needed revisions in five key areas: the definition of rape, the definition of consent, the close-in-age exception, marital rape and the statute of limitations.
The bill drafted by the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs proposes treating non-consensual sexual relations involving or between sexual and gender minorities as rape. However, the advocacy paper recommends revising this provision in line with the United Nations Model Rape Law.
It states that the law should provide equal legal protection to all individuals without discrimination based on sex or gender identity. It also recommends defining rape as any non-consensual act of sexual penetration, however slight, of the vagina, anus or mouth using any body part or object.
Sexploration season 2 Episode 1:Sex and porn education for youn...
The paper also recommends defining consent as an explicit agreement given voluntarily and out of one’s free will. It says the law should clearly state that consent cannot be presumed from a victim’s silence, failure to resist, previous sexual history, profession or relationship with the accused.
It further recommends revising the phrase “not in a sound state of mind” in Section 219 (2) (b) of the proposed bill to explicitly include unconsciousness, sleep and conditions in which a person cannot give consent due to alcohol or drug consumption.
The advocacy paper also calls for changes to the proposed provision on consensual sexual relations between adolescents below the age of 18, which determines punishment based on the age difference between them. The bill proposes imprisonment of up to one year for consensual sexual relations between adolescents whose age difference is two years or less.
Instead, the paper recommends completely excluding consensual sexual relations from the scope of criminal offences when both adolescents are at least 14 years old and their age difference does not exceed two years. However, it says cases involving fear, threats, inducement, exploitation or abuse of power and authority should not fall under this exception and should remain subject to strict punishment.
The proposed provision on marital rape also needs revision, according to the recommendations. The bill proposes imprisonment of three to five years if a husband rapes his wife while the marital relationship remains legally intact. However, the advocacy paper argues that marital rape should carry the same legal definition and punishment as other forms of rape, regardless of marital status.
The paper also recommends completely abolishing the statute of limitations for rape cases to ensure survivors’ access to justice and prevent perpetrators from escaping legal action.
Noting that a large number of sexual violence survivors do not come forward to file complaints, FWLD Executive Director and lawyer Sabin Shrestha said incorporating all five proposed amendments would create a more supportive environment for survivors to report such cases.